Last year, I had fun swatching Alibi, Manuscript, P.I., and Swoon over black eyeliner to see what would happen (spoiler alert: Alibi changes color).
Clearly, The Wild Hunt and Gleeman are the most dramatic, with their color shifting (no wonder I adore them). Uplift gets even more shimmery over black, like the cocktail dress of eyeshadow. Stargazer I expected more pizzaz from than I got, but if you’re looking for a way to tone down a black eyeliner, then here’s one way.
What do you think- which is your favorite?